The .45-70 Government cartridge, a legendary round with a rich history, continues to captivate shooters today. Two names consistently rise to the top when discussing lever-action rifles chambered in this powerful caliber: Henry and Marlin. But which reigns supreme? This in-depth comparison dives into the nuances of Henry and Marlin .45-70 rifles, helping you choose the perfect firearm for your needs.
Design and Build Quality
Both Henry and Marlin offer robust lever-action rifles, but their designs differ in key aspects.
Henry .45-70
Henry rifles are renowned for their solid construction and attractive aesthetics. Their .45-70 models typically feature a strong, well-finished receiver and a noticeably sturdy action. Many appreciate Henry's commitment to using American-made parts, contributing to their perceived higher quality. The fit and finish are generally excellent, reflecting a higher price point in some cases. However, some might find the action slightly heavier than Marlin's.
Marlin .45-70 (Pre-Remington and Post-Remington)
Marlin's legacy in lever-action rifles is undeniable. Pre-Remington Marlin .45-70 rifles are often considered highly collectible and sought-after by enthusiasts. Their actions were known for their smooth operation and robust construction. Post-Remington Marlin rifles, however, have received mixed reviews regarding quality control. While some remain reliable, others have experienced issues with inconsistencies in build quality. This is a crucial factor to consider when comparing the two brands.
Action and Operation
The lever action is the heart of both rifles. While both operate smoothly, subtle differences exist.
Henry's Action:
Henry rifles are celebrated for their smooth, reliable lever action. The action is typically a bit heavier, which contributes to a solid and dependable feel. Many find the action cycles smoothly and reliably.
Marlin's Action (Pre-Remington and Post-Remington):
Pre-Remington Marlins boasted a legendary action, appreciated for its ease of use and reliability. Post-Remington models have varied in quality. Some shooters report issues with the action's smoothness and reliability. This variability significantly impacts the overall user experience.
Features and Options
Both brands offer various features, impacting the overall shooting experience.
Henry's Features:
Henry often includes features such as fully adjustable sights, contributing to accurate shooting at various distances. They also frequently offer variations in stock material and finish, catering to different preferences.
Marlin's Features:
Marlin rifles have traditionally included features that cater to both hunting and target shooting, though availability has varied depending on the specific model and production year.
Price and Value
The price range for both Henry and Marlin .45-70 rifles varies widely depending on the model, condition (especially for used Marlins), and features.
Henry's Pricing:
Generally, Henry rifles command a higher price due to their reputation for quality and consistent construction. While expensive, many consider the investment worthwhile.
Marlin's Pricing:
Marlin rifles, particularly pre-Remington models, can be quite valuable on the collector's market. However, newer Marlin rifles may be more affordable, but potential quality issues should be considered.
Conclusion: Which is Right for You?
Choosing between a Henry and a Marlin .45-70 depends heavily on your priorities and budget.
-
Choose Henry if: You prioritize consistent quality, smooth action, American-made components, and are willing to pay a premium for a reliable rifle.
-
Choose Marlin (pre-Remington) if: You are a collector or can find a well-maintained pre-Remington model within your budget. These are highly valued and often represent excellent value for experienced shooters.
-
Proceed with caution regarding Marlin (post-Remington): Thoroughly research specific models and reviews before purchasing a post-Remington Marlin to gauge the reliability and quality control.
This comparison provides a solid starting point for your research. Always handle and inspect any firearm before purchasing and consider consulting with experienced shooters and gunsmiths for further guidance. Remember to always practice safe gun handling and adhere to all applicable laws and regulations.
