Choosing between a Glock 17 Gen 4 and a Gen 5 can feel overwhelming. Both are excellent handguns, but subtle differences cater to specific preferences and shooting styles. This in-depth comparison will highlight the key distinctions, helping you determine which generation best suits your needs. We'll examine features, ergonomics, performance, and ultimately, which Glock 17 reigns supreme.
Key Differences: Gen 4 vs. Gen 5 Glock 17
The Glock 17 Gen 5 represents a refinement of the Gen 4, addressing some user feedback and incorporating technological advancements. While both share the Glock reliability and robust design, their differences are significant enough to warrant careful consideration.
1. Frame Design and Texturing: Enhanced Grip and Control
-
Gen 4: Features interchangeable backstraps for customized grip size and feel. This allows shooters to adjust the pistol to fit their hand perfectly. The texturing is aggressive, providing a secure grip even in wet or sweaty conditions. However, some found the aggressive texture a bit harsh.
-
Gen 5: Eliminates the interchangeable backstraps, opting for a more refined and less aggressive texturing across the entire grip. Glock has listened to feedback regarding the Gen 4's texture and aimed for improved comfort without sacrificing grip. The absence of backstraps simplifies maintenance and reduces overall parts.
Which is better? This largely depends on personal preference. Shooters who appreciate customization and require a very secure grip might favor the Gen 4's backstraps. Those prioritizing a more comfortable, less abrasive texture and streamlined design will likely prefer the Gen 5.
2. Trigger and Trigger Mechanism: Smoother Shooting Experience?
-
Gen 4: Retains the familiar Glock trigger, known for its crisp break and relatively short reset.
-
Gen 5: Introduces an improved trigger with a smoother, more refined trigger pull. The trigger bar is redesigned for improved consistency and feel, resulting in a noticeably improved shooting experience for many users. The trigger connector has also been refined for enhanced performance.
Which is better? The Gen 5's refined trigger is generally considered superior, offering a more consistent and comfortable shooting experience. However, the Gen 4 trigger is perfectly serviceable and many shooters remain perfectly happy with it.
3. Slide Design and Features: Modernizing the Icon
-
Gen 4: Features front serrations on the slide, aiding in manipulation.
-
Gen 5: Improves upon the Gen 4 by incorporating ambidextrous slide serrations, making it easier for both right and left-handed shooters to rack the slide. The absence of the finger grooves on the Gen 5 slide provides a more streamlined and comfortable grip for many shooters.
Which is better? The ambidextrous slide serrations of the Gen 5 provide a clear advantage for versatility and ease of use for all shooters.
4. Barrel and Performance: Increased Accuracy Potential
-
Gen 4: Employs a standard Glock barrel.
-
Gen 5: Features a Marksman barrel, which is designed to improve accuracy through enhanced rifling and tolerances.
Which is better? The Gen 5's Marksman barrel contributes to improved accuracy and potentially better grouping at longer ranges. However, both barrels are reliable and capable.
Conclusion: Which Glock 17 is Right for You?
Ultimately, the "better" Glock 17 (Gen 4 vs. Gen 5) is subjective and depends heavily on individual preferences and shooting styles. The Gen 5 Glock 17 addresses some user feedback from the Gen 4, resulting in a refined and improved design in several key areas. However, the Gen 4 remains a highly capable and reliable handgun.
Consider these factors to make your decision:
-
Grip Preference: Prefer customizable grip and aggressive texturing? Gen 4 might be your choice. Prefer a more comfortable and less aggressive grip? Gen 5 is a strong contender.
-
Trigger Feel: Value a smoother, more refined trigger pull? The Gen 5's improved trigger is hard to beat.
-
Ambidextrous Use: Require ambidextrous slide serrations? Gen 5 is the clear winner.
-
Budget: Gen 4 models are often available at more competitive price points.
By carefully weighing these aspects and considering your individual needs, you can confidently choose between the Glock 17 Gen 4 and Gen 5 and find the perfect pistol for your shooting requirements.
