Choosing the right lever-action rifle in .45-70 Government can be a daunting task, especially with iconic names like Henry and Marlin in the mix. Both manufacturers produce high-quality firearms, but significant differences exist that cater to various shooting styles and preferences. This in-depth comparison will explore the key features, performance, and overall value of Henry and Marlin .45-70 lever-actions, helping you make an informed decision.
Key Differences: Henry vs. Marlin .45-70
While both rifles share the fundamental design of a lever-action, several key distinctions set them apart:
1. Receiver Material and Construction:
- Henry: Typically utilizes a solid brass receiver, contributing to a robust and durable firearm. Brass offers excellent corrosion resistance and contributes to the rifle's overall weight and feel. The brass receiver is a distinctive feature of many Henry rifles.
- Marlin (pre-Remington): Older Marlin .45-70s featured steel receivers, known for their strength and relative affordability. Post-Remington Marlin models present a more complicated picture with varying receiver materials and build quality depending on the specific model and year of manufacture. Consistency in build quality has been a point of concern for some shooters with post-Remington Marlins.
2. Action and Operation:
Both Henry and Marlin lever actions are known for their smooth operation. However, subtle differences in the lever design and action feel exist. Henry rifles often receive praise for a very smooth, easy-to-operate lever. Marlin's lever action is similarly renowned but may feel slightly different in hand. This is largely a matter of personal preference.
3. Stock and Wood:
Both brands offer variations in stock material and finish. You'll find options ranging from American walnut to more affordable synthetic stocks. The quality and feel of the wood (if applicable) can vary depending on the specific model and price point. Pay attention to the grain and overall finish when making your choice.
4. Sights and Optics:
Most models from both manufacturers will come equipped with basic iron sights. However, mounting optics can differ slightly. Both offer options for scope mounting, though the specific rail systems or drilling locations might vary. Carefully check the specifications for each rifle to ensure compatibility with your preferred optic setup.
5. Manufacturing and Quality Control:
Henry rifles generally maintain a reputation for high-quality manufacturing and consistent build quality. Marlin's reputation experienced a decline following its acquisition by Remington and subsequent bankruptcy. While some current Marlin models might be acceptable, it's crucial to carefully research specific models and production years when considering a Marlin .45-70. Look for reviews and user feedback to gauge the consistency of quality control for the model you are interested in.
6. Pricing:
Typically, Henry .45-70 rifles are priced slightly higher than comparable Marlin models (pre-Remington). This price difference often reflects the use of brass receivers and perceived higher manufacturing quality. However, pricing can fluctuate depending on market availability and specific model features.
Choosing the Right Rifle for You:
The "best" rifle depends entirely on your individual needs and priorities.
Choose a Henry .45-70 if:
- You prioritize a robust, durable rifle with a brass receiver.
- You value a consistently high-quality manufacturing process.
- A slightly smoother lever action is important to you.
- You're willing to pay a premium for a premium rifle.
Choose a Marlin .45-70 (pre-Remington) if:
- You're looking for a potentially more affordable option with a steel receiver (pre-Remington models).
- You're comfortable with the potential for some variation in build quality (this was less of a concern with pre-Remington models).
Choose a Marlin .45-70 (post-Remington) with caution:
- Thoroughly research the specific model and production year before purchasing.
- Check online reviews and forums to assess the quality control of the model in question. Proceed with caution, as reports of inconsistent quality exist.
Ultimately, handling both rifles and carefully examining their features in person is highly recommended before making a final decision. Consider your budget, intended use (hunting, target shooting, etc.), and personal preferences when making your choice. The .45-70 is a powerful cartridge, so ensure you are comfortable and proficient with its recoil before heading to the range.
